The Two Arenas of AI Search Optimization and the Process I Use to Win Both
Caleb Turner
on
March 19, 2026
If you want to win in AI search, you have to win two distinct, but related arenas. Getting retrieved and getting preferred.
I don’t treat AI visibility like a vanity ranking game. I care more about whether a brand is consistently pulled into the right conversations and preferred for high intent prompts.
The research supports that approach. The 2023 GEO study introduced Generative Engine Optimization and reported visibility gains of up to 40% from the right optimization methods.
The E-GEO: A Testbed for Generative Engine Optimization in E-Commerce study found that intent match, factuality, differentiation, and scannable formatting consistently improved ranking outcomes.
I look at AI search as a two-step system.
First, your brand has to get retrieved. That means your site, brand, or page has to make it into the possible answer set. Then, once you are in the set, you have to get preferred. That second step is the re-ranking layer, where the model decides which option is the clearest fit for the user’s prompt. The 2025 E-GEO paper formalizes that same retrieval-plus-ranking framework.
That is why I don’t separate off-page SEO from on-page AI optimization. Off-page authority, mentions, citations, links, and digital PR help you get pulled in. Clear, well-structured, evidence backed content helps you get chosen once you are there.
I do not chase vanity rankings. Ranking for a head term like IT managed services might look good in a dashboard, but it tells me almost nothing about whether I am visible when a real buyer is actually close to choosing a provider.
People looking to purchase are not stopping at short category phrases anymore. They are asking long, detailed, constraint-heavy buying questions like:
“We run a 12-location healthcare group in Dallas and need a HIPAA-compliant IT provider that can manage endpoints, harden Microsoft 365, support audits, and help with compliance documentation. Who should we talk to?”
“Which Dallas managed IT companies can provide backup and disaster recovery with a one-hour recovery time objective, a 15-minute recovery point objective, and 24/7 incident response?”
“We need a managed cybersecurity partner for a multi-site medical practice that can handle SIEM, endpoint detection, phishing training, and policy documentation. Who actually does all of that well?”
This shift is not a theory anymore. Amazon says shoppers are already using Rufus to type natural-language questions, compare options, and ask granular product questions, while Bain found that 42% of large language model users already use these platforms for shopping recommendations.
In other words, I care less about whether I “rank #1” for a trophy keyword and more about whether search engines and large language models consistently understand that my brand is a strong answer for the high-intent situations my market actually cares about. That is what matters.
The process I use to increase AI visibility
My process starts with query selection, not page editing.
First, I identify the money prompts. These are the commercial, comparison-driven, bottom-of-funnel queries that reflect how people actually ask for help today. Then I expand those into related prompt variations so I can see the full intent map around the topic.
After that, I compare my page against competing pages and measure which page is most semantically aligned to the query. If my page is weak, I do not guess why. I fix the relevance gap.
Then I optimize at the chunk level.
Modern AI systems often retrieve and reuse sections, not entire pages. That is why I built an internal workflow that pulls strong content chunks, scores them against the target query, rewrites the best chunk into cleaner formats, and then re-ranks the outputs to identify the version most likely to be extracted and preferred.
In practice, the best version is usually the one that is easiest to scan, easiest to trust, and easiest to quote.
What I like about the 2025 E-GEO study is that it pushes the conversation beyond hype.
The researchers tested more than 7,000 realistic product queries, evaluated 15 common rewriting heuristics, and found that the best results came from a stable pattern rather than a gimmick. The content that rose tended to align closely with user intent, preserve factual accuracy, clearly differentiate itself, and present information in a format that is easy for the model to process.
I have had conversations in person and even on my YouTube channel with industry leading colleagues like Nick Eubanks, Ross Simmonds, and Charles Floate, and even when the tactics vary, the same fundamentals keep coming up: build authority beyond your site, understand how people really search, and publish content that is clear enough to be reused in answers.
That is a big reason I believe AI visibility is not a trick. It is a discipline.
You need distribution. You need credibility. You need answer-ready content. And you need to stop measuring success with outdated vanity metrics that were built for a different search era.
AI visibility is not about gaming one prompt or chasing one keyword. It is about increasing the probability that your brand gets retrieved for the right conversations and is preferred when the model compares options.
Parent/head terms still matter as category and entity anchors for retrieval, internal linking, and query reformulation, but they do not deserve to be your primary measurement system for AI-era revenue visibility.
The KPI should be whether your brand is retrieved and preferred across the high-intent prompt set that real buyers actually use.
That means winning both arenas: off-page presence strong enough to get you into the set, and on-page structure strong enough to move you to the top.
That’s the process I use, and it’s the process I keep seeing validated by research, by testing, and by conversations with other people deep in this space. If you focus on those fundamentals, you stop chasing vanity and start building visibility that actually compounds. Schedule an introductory call with me today to discuss how we can do this for your brand.







































